Cardiff mother that fasted son to death during Covid-19 lockdown was insane, jury finds

A mother who caused the death of her toddler son by fasting him of food and water during the Covid-19 lockdown has been found not guilty by reason of insanity, a jury ruled.

Olabisi Abubakar, 42, from Cardiff, was found thin and dehydrated next to the body of her son, Taiwo, three, at their flat in Cathays in June 2020.

Cardiff Crown Court heard Ms Abubakar, who came to the UK from Nigeria as an asylum seeker in 2011, is a devout Pentecostal Christian who has fasted for many years as part of her faith.

The former hairdresser became “engulfed by her religious beliefs” and began fasting for long periods along with her young son due to fears over the pandemic as well as personal pressures, the court heard.

She was sectioned the day after police forced entry to her home on Cwmdare Street on 29 June 2020, following concerns for her welfare from a friend, and found Ms Abubakar malnourished and her son dead inside.

Ms Abubakar, who is detained in hospital for treatment for paranoid schizophrenia, was later charged with manslaughter and two counts of child cruelty.

On Friday, a jury at Cardiff Crown Court found her not guilty by reason of insanity to the three charges against her after four hours of deliberations upon which the defendant became visibly distressed.

Discharging the jury, Mrs Justice Jefford thanked the panel for their work.

She said: "It has been an unusual trial and this has been very different from most trials due to the agreement between the prosecution and the defence and the very sad circumstances of this case where someone had been a sociable, good and caring mother suffered from a serious mental illness which resulted in the death of her child."

She told them she was likely to impose hospital orders under Sections 37 and 41 of the Mental Health Act when the defendant returns to court next Tuesday.

During the trial, Mark Heywood KC, prosecuting, described how police officers forced entry into Ms Abubakar’s flat and found a "tragic and distressing scene”.

He added: “Her religion makes it clear that fasting is an act of devotion, and children – too young to understand this – should not fast.

"The evidence suggests that in 2020, fearful of the coronavirus pandemic and under personal pressure, she caused Taiwo to fast both food and water along with her.”

Police officers who searched Ms Abubaker’s flat after Taiwo’s body was discovered found a note on food in a fridge, stating: “Do not touch anything, whooping cough, virus, save yourself”.

Ms Abubakar wrote a series of notes while in an ambulance and in hospital, stating she was “very hungry” and “can’t stand up”.

In hospital, Ms Abubakar told a police officer: “I don’t eat, I can’t cook, because of coronavirus, I can’t go and buy food”.

Doctors found Ms Abubakar was suffering delusions and she was sectioned under the Mental Health Act 1983 on 30 June 2020.

Ms Abubakar, who attended her trial via video link from hospital, accepted she did the acts alleged, but said she was not guilty by reason of insanity.

In a police interview, she described how she had been “locking herself away” due to Covid-19 and believed she had fallen asleep on June 26, before being brought back from heaven when police arrived.

She told officers: “I saw myself among the dead in heaven. I was saying: ‘I don’t want to die.’ Then I saw the angels of God and they brought me back to life.”

Following the verdicts, Taiwo’s father released a statement in which he described his son as an “amazing boy”.

“The first time I saw Taiwo, he gave me such joy, I was fulfilled,” he said.

“I wish Taiwo was still with us, but I want to remember him as the happy, talkative boy that he was.”

Want a quick and expert briefing on the biggest news stories? Listen to our latest podcasts to find out What You Need To Know…