ECJ rules benefits can be denied to jobless migrants

The European Court of Justice has ruled benefits can be denied to jobless migrants if they have never held a job in that country.

Dubbed "benefits tourism", it has occurred in many EU countries for some time.

But today Germany won the right to refuse to pay a Romanian woman and her son benefits on that basis.

Live updates

Defining 'benefit tourism' and what it means for Britain

In a ruling that could have been written by the Prime Minister himself, the European Court of Justice says it's all right for countries to limit benefits to certain unemployed migrants.

The case involved a Romanian mother and son who applied for benefits in Germany. Mr Cameron called the judgement common sense.

ITV News political correspondent Libby Wiener explains what it means for so called benefit tourism:

IDS: Benefits tourism decision an 'excellent ruling'

Secretary of State for Work and Pensions Iain Duncan Smith. Credit: PA

Work and Pensions Secretary Iain Duncan Smith said the Government would work with administrations across Europe to assess the wider implications of the so-called 'benefits tourism' ruling by the European Court of Justice.

This is an excellent ruling - and supports our view that people coming to the UK who don't have sufficient resources to support themselves and would become a unreasonable burden should not be able access national welfare systems.

The fact Germany's decision was challenged in this way is yet more evidence that the EU needs a much clearer legal framework, clarifying the original Treaties, allowing member states to retain control over their own national welfare systems.

– Work and Pensions Secretary Iain Duncan Smith

Advertisement

Tory MEP: Benefits tourism ECJ ruling 'common sense'

A Tory MEP has said that The European Court of Justice has ruled in favour of common sense in restricting so-called "benefits tourism".

The European Court of Justice has ruled in favour of common sense. The court has made it clear that the original purpose of free movement is to allow free movement of labour and not of benefits tourists.

If people cannot support themselves or make a meaningful contribution to the economy then they can have their benefits curbed, even if they are non-contributory benefits.

– Tory MEP Anthea McIntyre and employment spokeswoman

The case involved a Romanian woman and her son who had been denied access to certain benefits under the German system.

Benefits can be denied to jobless migrants, court rules

Credit: PA

The European Court of Justice has ruled benefits can be denied to jobless migrants if they have never held a job in that country.

Dubbed "benefits tourism", it has occurred in many EU countries for some time.

But today Germany won the right to refuse to pay a Romanian woman and her son benefits on that basis.

The ECJ said EU countries must be allowed to withhold some benefits to "economically inactive union citizens who exercise their right to freedom of movement solely in order to obtain another member state's social assistance".

It could now have wide ranging impacts on the rest of Europe, including the UK.

A Downing Street spokesman said David Cameron welcomed the ruling and "will look very carefully at what we and other governments can do in response to this judgment."

Back to top

Latest ITV News reports