Women’s treatment in Greater Manchester Police custody ‘needs urgent change’
Zoe Muldoon has been speaking to one victim's father Marlon, as well as one woman who although not included in the findings, actually prompted the inquiry after going public about her experience in custody in Salford
Women were "unlawfully and unnecessarily" arrested by Greater Manchester Police with officers often taking the side of the other party over them, an "explosive" report has found.
One girl, who was just 14 at the time she was arrested, was found to have been unlawfully strip searched and has now been left terrified of police, it added.
The investigation into the experience of women and girls arrested and taken into custody by the force was commissioned after a number accused Greater Manchester Police (GMP) of unjustified strip searches after being detained.
Dame Vera Baird KC, the former victims’ commissioner for England and Wales, said her report must drive urgent change within the force and nationally.
As part of the report Dame Vera also interviewed three men, one of whom was left severely injured and naked after force was used inside a police cell.
Seven of the 15 who were interviewed were found to have been unlawfully arrested, she said.
GMP has previously denied any wrongdoing by its staff.
The report detailed experiences of women across nine custody suites who were left begging for sanitary products, naked, unable to use the toilet, or without medication.
Scarlett West, who was just 14 when she was arrested, was abused, groomed and trafficked from her early teens.
She was unlawfully strip searched with in custody - with no appropriate adult present - leaving her "deeply humiliated", after officers thought she was hiding an e-cigarette.
Scarlett, who has waived her anonymity, was detained for more than 24 hours - with Dame Baird's report finding the lack of care for the teenager was "clear".
Marlon West, Scarlett's dad, said: "She's been raped, sexually abused, then going into the care of the police, they're looking after a 14-year-old girl, to then strip search her down to her knickers and bra.
"One of the things for Scarlett is she is terrified of GMP, she thinks there's going to be problems afterwards from GMP.
"She really believes there will be consequences for taking part in this review.
"Because of her experiences with GMP previously and the way she has been treated on other occasions, she fears that she will be arrested."
In her report, Dame Vera recommends strip searching should be severely limited, properly regulated and fully recorded, and that custody officers should be reminded of their responsibilities for the accuracy and completeness of custody records.
Dame Vera, who makes recommendations for consideration both within the force and nationally, said: “I hope that my inquiry and this report will drive change where it is - sometimes urgently - required in GMP.
“My aim is strongly to promote a way of working in the police that will justifiably engender trust across the population and particularly among women.”
Former GMP detective Maggie Oliver described the inquiry as “another damning indictment of one of the country’s largest police forces”.
She said: “Dame Vera Baird’s explosive report reveals a shocking disregard for rights of those coming into contact with the criminal justice system.
Ms Oliver, who has since founded The Maggie Oliver Foundation, a charity supporting adult survivors of childhood sexual abuse, said: “Many of those arrested were vulnerable women and we say that this constitutes a very serious abuse of power.”
Dame Vera interviewed more than 15 people who had been arrested and detained by GMP, including three women featured in a Sky News investigation.
Custody records, detention logs, crime reports, witness statements and CCTV footage were among documents and data that were trawled through.
In recalling her strip search, a woman given the name Maria to preserve her anonymity, told the inquiry: “The only reason they did what they did was to degrade me … If I was a man, I don’t think they would’ve done it. I was treated like a piece of meat.”
Dame Vera has set out recommendations on domestic abuse, better custody provision especially for women, improved risk assessment and more humane and dignified treatment of all detainees, a lay presence in police custody and also on arrests.
GMP should refresh officer training for cases where voluntary attendance could have been available.
The report states: “The inquiry’s conclusion is that many of these arrests were unnecessary or unlawful.
“In cases at the lower levels of alleged criminality, the balance should favour avoiding both the risk of poor impact on arrestees and the risk to public confidence from such arrests.”
On arrests, Dame Vera notes: “It is of concern that in a number of cases in this inquiry where there is a continuing dispute, the police appear to have supported one side and taken criminal justice action – in particular, arrest – against the other party.”
A scrutiny panel could perhaps help if there is “evidence of a wider pattern and, if so, to probe the causes and, if necessary, prescribe solutions”, she added.
Marlon says he does not believe the report's recommendations go far enough.
"I feel really, really strongly now that it is highlighted again how people are treated by the police," he said.
"There should be a public inquiry because this is in the interests of the public.
"I want change, not just for Scarlett but for the people of Manchester, there needs to be clear changes."
The report states: “GMP, the NPCC (National Police Chief’s Council) and the Home Office should, forthwith, investigate the potential for use of equipment such as airport screening devices to eradicate degrading strip searching from police practice as much as possible. GMP could lead this endeavour.”
Nationally, work could be done to see if two levels of strip searching, varying from thorough to intimate with the appropriate go-ahead, could be introduced.
GMP should participate in this work and pilot the model proposed in this report to move this “urgent agenda forward”, Dame Vera suggests.
She adds: “From now on in GMP, if any strip search is contemplated, the detainee must be asked whether they have something with them they know they would not be allowed to keep, to give the detainee the option of offering items up.
“From now on in GMP, the reasons why any strip search is required must be explained to the detainee by the custody sergeant to the detainee in plain language, relating (a) facts and circumstances justifying it, and (b) why there is no alternative.”
Breaches of the Victims’ Code Rights, which obliges the force to give support to victims of sexual and domestic abuse, were found in the cases of Maria and Dannika, according to Dame Vera.
She said: “Maria was very badly treated by GMP”, and as a domestic abuse victim she should have had a link to the officer in her case and to a local domestic abuse charity via the 24-hour national helpline so that her support needs could have been met without six hours of telephoning the police to get help.
The victims of the predator reported by Dannika were not referred for tailored victim support, they were not given a crime reference and an officer number, and were not updated on progress with the case.
Dame Vera describes the police responses in Maria’s case as being “on a continuum between bureaucratic and unhelpful, and none of them acknowledges the police obligation to victims” plus the strip search custody record note does not refer to the power under which it was carried out.
GMP says it has "apologised and accepted the recommendations of an inquiry".
The force added: "While some improvements to address Dame Vera’s recommendations have already been made, we fully acknowledge there is much more to do around the cultural practice of strip-search, particularly for welfare purposes."
Chief Constable Stephen Watson said: "The issues raised in Dame Vera’s report speaks to a period when our custody system was under pressure not performing to an acceptable standard.
“It evidences poor systems, structures, and incivility, insensitivity and compounded by a lack of routine leadership, scrutiny, and individual examples of low standards, poor behaviour, insensitivity, and a lack of care in the face of vulnerability."
He added: "“We accept the recommendations in this report. We commit to implementing them fully and faithfully with a view to making lasting improvements.
“Our ability to take forward the recommendations is immensely strengthened by the substantial progress we have already made.
“We will work with others to ensure that all of the wider recommendations are fully considered and, wherever possible, will seek out opportunities for GMP to play a leading role in their practical implementation to ensure the people of GM get the best possible service.”
Want more on the issues affecting the North? Our podcast, From the North answers the questions that matter to our region.