Bailiwick fishermen banned from UK and EU waters

The temporary ban on Guernsey fisherman entering EU and UK waters was lifted today.

Guernsey's fishermen were banned last month from fishing in UK and EU waters in a row over quotas.

The shock move appeared to be because fishermen do not have to abide by any quota limits in Bailiwick waters.

Live updates

Fishing ban in EU and UK waters lifted

Credit: Fishing boat

The temporary ban on Guernsey fisherman entering EU and UK waters was lifted today.

The UK suspended the Fisheries Management Agreement between the UK and the Bailiwick last month in a row over quotas. It also suspended the reciprocal UK licences held by Bailiwick fishermen.

DEFRA have agreed to lift the suspension on the reciprocal licences issued to Guernsey registered vessels by the MMO but have not lifted the suspension on the Fisheries Management Agreement at this time.

The suspension came as a surprise to fishermen and Commerce and Employment Minister, Kevin Stewart, who called the move 'irrational'.

The UK government's Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) said Guernsey had not been honouring the agreement they signed, and are refusing to comply with the Common Fisheries Policy rules.

The Department has been advised that this has been done as "a sign of good faith" whilst further discussions take place and that these licences are restored "pending the outcome of these discussions.

Following the lifting of the suspension of the reciprocal fishing licences held by Bailiwick vessels by the MMO, officials from the States of Guernsey met DEFRA officials in London today. These are sensitive issues and we have had productive discussions with DEFRA on a range of matters. We are working on a number of options together in order to try and seek a resolution in a timely manner and these discussions will be ongoing.

– Statement a Policy Council and Commerce & Employment Dept spokesperson

UK Minister accused of behaving like "bully" over Guernsey fishing row

UK Fisheries Minister George Eustice has been accused of behaving like a "bully" over the current fishing dispute with Guernsey.

Officials at Westminster have banned Guernsey fishermen from working in EU and UK waters after the island's government refused to introduce fishing quotas.

The States argues its licensing system is an adequate way to ensure the sustainability of fish stocks.

Today, in the Sunday Telegraph, columnist Christopher Brooker argues the UK's move is illegal, and threatens to damage the constitutional relationship between there and the Bailiwick of Guernsey.

Mr Eustice has provoked an absurdly damaging and thoroughly unnecessary crisis. Someone above him in London needs urgently to tell him that he must stop behaving like a school bully who seeks out the smallest boy in the playground to beat up, in the hope that no one is watching.

– Christopher Brooker

You can read the full comment piece here.

In the past fortnight, Guernsey's government has told island fishermen it has no plan to introduce quotas and back down.

The Chief Minister has written to Lord Faulks, who looks after the relationship between Westminster and the Channel Islands to intervene and break the deadlock.

Advertisement

Fishermen told Guernsey won't introduce quotas

Guernsey fishermen have been told the island won't agree to quotas.

Locals are currently banned from UK and EU waters as the UK pressures the island to observe limits on ray and skate catches.

Fishermen met with politicians last night and told ITV News that the government said it will do all it can to reverse the situation, but that it can't, and won't bring in quotas.

Dougal Lane from the Guernsey Fishermen's Association said fishermen left feeling reassured by what the government said.

Those fishermen affected by the ban will have to wait until the situation is resolved before they can fish outside of Guernsey waters.

Guernsey 'won't consider introducing fishing quotas'

Guernsey says it will not consider introducing fishing quotas.

That's despite the UK suspending the Fisheries Management Agreement, which stops some island fishermen from using UK and EU waters.

It is thought that is because the Bailiwick won't apply UK quotas.

The Commerce and Employment Minister says quotas would 'decimate' the industry in the island.

Somehow the UK have got themselves into a pickle over their own quotas but I am sorry, Guernsey is not the answer to that. We made it very clear when we negotiated the FMA that we could not have quotas. Our fishermen survive on skate and ray and those stocks are sustanible and are endorsed by other organisations, not just the States of Guernsey Sea Fisheries

– Deputy Kevin Stewart, Commerce and Employment Minister

Fisherman have told ITV News that they agree that quotas would not be good for the island.

Traditionally, or historically we've caught between 200 and 250 tonnes of ray, and that's been going on for years and years and years. And I believe last year it dropped a little bit as we had fewer boats on the ground but they're offering us about 35 tonnes a year, which wouldn't actually keep one boat going.

– DOUGAL LANE, GUERNSEY FISHERMEN'S ASSOCIATION

Guernsey won't be taking immediate action on UK fishing ban

Guernsey's Commerce and Employment Minister says they won't be taking immediate action on the UK's fishing ban.

This week the UK suspended the Fisheries Management Agreement between the UK and the Bailiwick, as well as the reciprocal UK licences held by Bailiwick fishermen.

Deputy Kevin Stewart says they still haven't had the details of the ban, despite them coming into action today.

He says the decision is 'very serious' for some fisherman and that the government must consider all options before taking any action.

Advertisement

Minister says decision to ban fishing is 'irrational'

Jersey’s Minister for Commerce and Employment says the UK's decision to ban Bailiwick fishermen from UK and EU waters is “irrational”.

Deputy Kevin Stewart also says the statement given by The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra)was “inaccurate”. He says there are no reference to fishing quotas in the Fisheries Monitoring and Analysis (FMA).

It is thought the ban is due to Guernsey's policy not to apply UK quota controls in local waters.

Although DEFRA say they have been in discussion with Guernsey about the matter since March, Deputy Stewart says the States had “absolutely no notice” that the ban would be given.

UK says banning Bailiwick fishing is 'last resort' in row

Credit: PA stills

The UK department who have forced a ban on Bailiwick fishermen entering UK and EU waters say they have been forced to do so as a last resort.

The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) says Guernsey have not been honouring the agreement they signed, and are refusing to comply with the Common Fisheries Policy rules.

They say they have been working with Guernsey’s government since March on the issue.

When the ruling was announced this morning though, Commerce and Employment Minister Deputy Kevin Stewart said the decision had come completely “out of the blue”.

Defra says they hope banning Guernsey fishermen is a “temporary measure”.

This action is a last resort in response to Guernsey not honouring the terms of the agreement they signed, and not complying with the rules of the Common Fisheries Policy, which is designed to protect stock levels with quotas

We have worked with Guernsey since March to try and come to a mutual agreement, but Guernsey has regrettably refused to introduce a ceiling on their skates and ray catch which is not sustainable, nor is it a fair use of quota.

It is important we protect the long-term future of our fisheries and quotas play a crucial role in ensuring the sustainability of our stock. We understand the impact on local fishermen and hope this will be a temporary situation.

– Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra)

'We know very little' say fishermen banned from UK waters

Fishermen in Guernsey say they know very little about today's shock announcement, banning them from fishing in UK and EU waters.

The UK announced this morning, that it is to suspend a reciprocal agreement between fishermen there and the those in the Bailiwick from 1st August.

It is thought it is because of Guernsey's policy not to apply UK quota controls in local waters.

Commerce and Employment say the decision came "out of the blue" and fishermen say they are in the dark too.

We've all been up the Sea Fisheries to find out what's going on and they actually know very little. They've arranged a meeting next Thursday evening for every licensed fisherman and by then, hopefully, we'll know a bit more.

– Dougal Lane, Guernsey Fishermen's Association

Fishing ban will affect maximum of 10 boats

Credit: Hrvoje Jelavic/PIXSELL/Pixsell/Press Association Images

The decision to ban Bailiwick fishermen from UK and EU waters will affect a maximum of 10 boats.

Two main boats are said to regularly travel to UK waters to fish. Five to ten boats enter the waters on a more occasional basis. Fishermen have today said it is early days and they do not know too much as of yet.

Commerce and Employment the say the Sea Fisheries team have contacted all those affected. A briefing for the Bailiwick wide fishing industry is being organised for next week.

Load more updates Back to top