Leicester husband who beat wife to death with hockey stick before jumping off Norfolk cliff jailed
Warning: This article contains content that readers may find distressing
A husband who beat his wife to death with a hockey stick and then cut her head off with a wooden saw, before attempting to kill himself, has been jailed.
Kaushik Solanki, 55, of Humberstone, Leicester, survived the fall, and was jailed for his crimes.
Solanki denied murdering his wife, Manisha, but pleaded guilty to her manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility.
He said years of abuse in the marriage, made worse by lockdown during the Covid-19 pandemic, led to his mental health problems deteriorating.
The Crown Prosecution Service agreed to drop the original murder charge.
There had been violence between Solanki and Manisha that had resulted in numerous visits from Leicestershire Police, who had advised the couple to separate.
Solanki had been in the process of divorcing Manisha when he attacked her at their home in Hamilton, Leicester, on either 14 or 15 April last year.
He wrote a suicide note to his nephew before driving to Hunstanton, on the Norfolk coast, where he threw himself from the clifftop onto the rocks below - observed by a couple who happened to be watching a live webcam of the seaside while eating their breakfast.
They called the emergency services, who found Solanki at the bottom of the cliff, still conscious but with his face "smashed", his arms and legs broken and a serious brain injury.
Solanki was flown to hospital near Cambridge and his life was saved. He is expected to make a full recovery within about 18 months.
Appearing in a wheelchair at Loughborough Magistrates' Court, which was sitting as Leicester Crown Court, Solanki was sentenced by Judge Timothy Spencer QC.
The judge heard a list of 16 reasons for the spiral of the couple's marriage, including "empty nest syndrome" after their sons left for university, and their mental health issues that were made worse from 2020 when the Covid lockdowns began.
During the sentencing hearing, the court was played various video clips recorded by Solanki of his wife's behaviour, in which he was attacked and sworn at.
The judge said he took into account that Solanki was filming the incidents for the police, which would have affected his own behaviour in the footage, and that both were probably "as bad as each other".
Gordon Aspen QC, prosecuting, showed the judge pictures of 49-year-old Manisha's body, which was found in the utility room of their detached home in Tennis Court Drive, Humberstone, Leicester, within about two hours of Solanki, now 55, jumping off the cliff.
The judge was also shown diagrams of the injuries to Manisha's body, including a severe fracture to the right side of her skull and breaks on both her hands and forearms as she desperately tried to defend herself.
The court heard that Manisha worked with youngsters with special education needs at Leicester College, while Solanki, a former textile company owner, worked as a driver for Leicester City Council transporting disabled people.
On 14 April - which the court heard was likely the day of the killing - Solanki had just been reprimanded by his council bosses for an incident that was not discussed in court.
The marriage began to deteriorate in 2016, the court heard and, by the time of the killing, a "truly toxic and acrimonious situation existed between them," Mr Aspen said.
He said no explanation had been given by Solanki for what he did, but that it was likely "Mr Solanki lost his self-control as a result of an argument".
Mr Aspen said the domestic abuse began in 2016, and from 2018 the police were called to the address on "a number of occasions", although neither Solanki nor his wife ever made a formal complaint, and there were never serious injuries.
Solanki kept a sawn-off hockey stick in the house in case of a burglary. Mr Aspen said: "That weapon was used to beat Manisha to death. He inflicted no less than 11 blunt force trauma wounds to her.
"After killing Manisha, this defendant bound her legs with cable ties, secured cable ties and a dressing gown cord around her neck, and made a determined effort to decapitate her with a wood saw."
Timeline of events surrounding Manisha's death
Wednesday 14 April - 7pm
A neighbour's CCTV from the other side of Tennis Court Drive captured Solanki arriving home, followed by his wife at about 7.20pm.
Thursday 15 April - 5:39am
Solanki left to take his suicide note - along with cash, jewellery and an SD data card with evidence about his marital problems - to his nephew's home.
Mr Aspen said the note was clearly written by a "man in turmoil".
It said: "I am sorry for what I have done. The SD card has all the abuse I've suffered.
"I want to kill myself. I was mentally suffering for a long time."
The note did not mention he had killed his wife, but his nephew contacted the police later that morning after reading the note and having a brief conversation with Solanki.
During the conversation, the nephew pleaded with Solanki not to kill himself and asked where Manisha was - but Solanki just replied that he wanted his nephew to arrange his funeral.
He walked off the cliff edge at 9.08am that morning but, Mr Aspen said, "miraculously survived".
When Leicestershire Police forced their way into the family home they discovered what Mr Aspen said was a "truly grotesque and obscene spectacle".
Siobhan Grey QC, representing Solanki, said the case was "exceptional".
She referred to impact statements from the couple's sons, now aged 23 and 26, which described Manisha as "aggressive" and "the scary one" and Solanki not reacting with violence during the attacks upon him.
One son also sent his mum a text berating her and saying "physical abuse was wrong".
'The defendant had snapped' - court hears
Ms Grey said: "He would not react with physical violence. He would bottle it up inside him."
She added: "Covid exacerbated the dire situation at home".
Ms Grey said Solanki desperately sought help through his GP and charities such as Relate and The Samaritans, but struggled to get help because of the pandemic restrictions.
She also referred to a police statement from Solanki's brother, who "suggested he should retaliate in some way" after seeing Solanki's injuries.
"But he said he loved her," Ms Grey said.
Describing the killing, she said: "The defendant had snapped. It wasn't just one life - he sought to take his own life, too."
Judge Spencer told Solanki: "Your onslaught was unrelenting and merciless. Mercifully, she would have been rendered unconscious fairly swiftly.
"The photographs of her state when found by the police are truly shocking. Having killed her you set about tying her up and dismembering her.
"That was wholly unnecessary and represented a shocking humiliation of the now dead body of your wife."
'You bottled things up and your depression got worse'
The judge said the aggravating factor of the violence used was balanced out by both the fact he was in an "intolerable domestic situation" and the injuries he suffered trying to kill himself.
Describing the recordings of physical violence against Solanki, the judge said: "Of the two of you, she was more demonstrative and more physical - you bottled things up and your depression got worse and worse."
He said the earlier police officer's warning to the couple that they should live apart had been "very wise advice".
Solanki was jailed for 10 years. He will spend half of that behind bars, minus 248 days already spent in prison.
Leicestershire Police, which usually releases custody images of criminals when they are jailed for three years or more, said they had been asked by the family not to release a picture of Solanki.
Help and support:
If you need support or advice about anything visit our advice page.
Call the 24-hour National Domestic Abuse helpline on 0808 2000 247 for confidential, non-judgemental information and support.
Women's Aid - for information and support, email helpline@womensaid.org.uk or use the instant messaging service.
Contact a local domestic abuse service by using the Domestic Abuse Directory.
If you are in immediate danger, call 999.
When life is difficult, Samaritans are here – day or night, 365 days a year. You can call them for free on 116 123, email them at jo@samaritans.org.