Eyewitness describes moment Ryan Kirkpatrick was stabbed in Carlisle

An eyewitness to a fatal stabbing in Carlisle has told a jury she saw the moment Ryan Kirkpatrick was attacked.

Kane Hull, 29, of no fixed address, and Liam Craig Porter, 33, of Fulmar Place, Carlisle, both deny charges which allege murder and, alternatively, manslaughter of 24-year-old Mr Kirkpatrick, who was stabbed multiple times on 18 September 2021.

Both Hull and Porter deny being present at Carlyle’s Court at this time, but admit they were there during an incident earlier the same evening.

One of the bystanders who was present when the second incident occurred gave evidence from the witness box on Monday 17 October.

Chloe Bowman, a friend of Mr Kirkpatrick, had gone to the Mamoa bar within Carlyle’s Court between 8.30pm and 9pm.

Miss Bowman said she heard Mr Kirkpatrick tell a group of people — including her — about the previous incident, which she had not witnessed.

She was sitting on a bench outside Mamoa, with Mr Kirkpatrick about three metres away. 

“I just seen Kane enter the court and stab Ryan,” she said.

Prosecutor Tim Evans asked: “When you say ‘Kane’, who is the ‘Kane you are referring to?”

Miss Bowman said: “Kane Hull.”

Asked how long she had known Kane Hull, Miss Bowman said: “I just really knew of him. I knew of him for about two years.”

Asked how many times she saw Mr Kirkpatrick being stabbed, Miss Bowman told jurors: “I seen the once. I just saw the one time. Ryan was obviously bleeding from the lower bit of his body. Obviously we knew something bad had happened. I was in shock.” 

She added: “Obviously when the stabbing had finished we did try to help him.”

Asked what the attacker was wearing, Miss Bowman recalled a dark tracksuit and a balaclava.

“How were you able to see it was ‘Kane Hull’?” asked Mr Evans.

Miss Bowman replied: “Because Kane had intentions to come back and do it.”

Mr Evans asked: “Tell me what it was about this person in dark clothing with a balaclava that allowed you to recognise it was ‘Kane Hull’?”

“I could recognise him anyways from, like, his eyes. I could tell it was him because I knew of him,” replied Miss Bowman, who added: “From his build.”

Miss Bowman said she had drunk two bottles of wine before going into town, and also what she agreed could have been three Pornstar Martini cocktails by the time of the incident.

“That’s right, yeah,” she told Hull’s barrister, Toby Hedworth KC, as he suggested such alcohol intake would mean not having the clearest version of what was happening, “but I still remember what happened.”

Miss Bowman conceded she was “very drunk”.

She admitted saying in a sworn deposition made before the trial that she “knew” it was Hull, and stating: “I could see his eyes and heard his voice.”

She told jurors she didn’t know Hull’s actual voice — only that she heard the attacker speak.

“His intention was to come back anyways; when he has turned up I’ve known it’s him. It’s not going to be someone else, is it,” said Miss Bowman.

Mr Hedworth suggested to her: “That’s the reality: you can’t identify this person with only their eyes showing. You’re coming to the conclusion that whoever had had the trouble with Ryan the first time was the same person coming back.”

Miss Bowman replied: “Yeah.”

The trial continues.

Want a quick and expert briefing on the biggest news stories? Listen to our latest podcasts to find out What You Need To Know...