Prisoner's murder conviction quashed by Court of Appeal over dates mix-up

Stuart Layden was jailed for the murder of Ian Church in Great Yarmouth - the conviction has now been quashed.
Credit: Norfolk Police

A man convicted of murder has had his conviction quashed by the Court of Appeal because of a procedural error.

Stuart Layden was convicted in a retrial in 2016 for murdering Ian Church, 40, in Great Yarmouth in 2012, and given a life sentence with a minimum term of nine years.

That was a retrial after the quashing of a previous murder conviction, but prosecutors did not ask him to enter pleas for that retrial - known as an arraignment hearing - within two months.

Court of Appeal judges have ruled that missing that two-month time limit meant that Layden's conviction was unsafe.

Ian Church died in hospital in May 2012. Credit: Norfolk Police

The judgement states: "The appellant [Mr Layden] was not arraigned on a fresh indictment within two months of the order for a retrial following the quashing of the appellant’s conviction.

"[Secondly] at no time did the prosecution obtain an extension of time for such arraignment under section 8 (and arraign within any extended period)."

It concludes: "In these circumstances, the Crown Court did not have jurisdiction to try the appellant."

Mr Church, from Great Yarmouth, died at the James Paget University Hospital after being attacked outside a pub in the town.

He suffered serious head injuries during the incident outside the Bricklayers Arms in Nelson Road Central early on Saturday, 5 May.

Three other men are already serving sentences for his murder.


Want a quick and expert briefing on the biggest news stories? Listen to our latest podcasts to find out What You Need To Know