'Literally beaten black': Court shown messages between Sara Sharif's stepmother and sister
Sara Sharif’s stepmother texted her sister that the 10-year-old had been "literally beaten black" by her father and blamed her for the beatings she received, a court has heard.
Beinash Batool, 30, Sara’s father Urfan Sharif, 42, and uncle Faisal Malik, 29 are accused of carrying out a campaign of abuse culminating in her murder on August 8 last year.
Batool and Sharif have blamed each other for the violence in the family home in Woking, Surrey, with university student Malik claiming he was not involved.
On Thursday, jurors were read out a series of WhatsApp messages between 2020 and 2023 in which Batool relayed to her sister Qandeela Saboohi beatings Sharif had allegedly carried out on Sara.
The texts were accompanied by pictures of a grim-faced and bruised Sara, with the message: “Look what he’s doing. Delete the pictures.”
Batool repeatedly complained to her sister that Sharif was hitting Sara for being “naughty”, “rude and rebellious” and because she had cut up his clothes, hidden keys and torn up documents.
Ms Saboohi advised her to listen to the Quran, and when Batool talked about going to the police, told her to calm down.
Commenting on 10 photographs she sent of Sara, she wrote: “This is how bad he is beating her … I feel really sorry for her. He beat the crap out of her.”
Batool said that Sara had cut her father’s clothes for being mean. She told her sister: “She’s got a jinn in her. She reminds me of me when I was young.”
On another occasion, Batool said Sharif “went ballistic” and “beat Sara up like crazy”, expressing fears that he would break her arm or leg.
In May 2021, Batool told Ms Saboohi: “Not great in our house, it’s all a bit manic. Urfan beat the crap out of Sara and my mind is all in bits. I really want to report him.
“Why the hell doesn’t Urfan learn – she’s covered in bruises, literally beaten black.”
Afterwards, Sharif sat “on his fat bum” and played the board game Ludo, she said.
She went on: “Why the hell I’m even letting him in the house. I’m sorry for Sara, poor girl cannot walk. She literally fainted in the kitchen in the morning. He made her do sit-ups all night.”
Subscribe free to our weekly newsletter for exclusive and original coverage from ITV News. Direct to your inbox every Friday morning.
Asked what Sara had done, Batool said: “Because she hid the keys.”
By 2022, Batool said she was planning on taking “legal advice” but was advised by her sister to give it time and not rush.
Later that year, Batool said that she was considering taking Sara out of school, saying: “I don’t want to but kinda don’t have a choice.
“It’s not hard home schooling. I’m just fed up of her behaviour and Urfan’s. Sara’s body is literally bruised because Urfan beat her up. I cannot even cover it up."
Days later, she relayed that Sara’s school was worried about her and Sharif was “stressed” about it.
In apparent reference to Sara’s injuries, she wrote: “Urfan told me to cover it up with makeup and she’s going to wear sunglasses.”
The day before Sara died, Ms Saboohi tried to make contact but Batool told her she was “not in the mood to speak”.
Two days later, the defendants were captured on CCTV as they prepared to board a flight to Pakistan from Heathrow Airport.
On August 10 last year, police found Sara’s body in a bunkbed after Sharif called from Pakistan to say he had beaten Sara up “too much” for “being naughty”.
Jurors have heard she suffered dozens of injuries, including burns and suspected human bite marks.
Previously, prosecutor William Emlyn Jones KC told jurors that it was in dispute whether messages Batool sent two of her sisters were accurate or gave a full picture.
All three defendants, formerly of Hammond Road, Woking, have denied murder and causing or allowing the death of a child between December 16 2022 and August 9 2023.
The Old Bailey trial was adjourned until Friday.
Want a quick and expert briefing on the biggest news stories? Listen to our latest podcasts to find out What You Need To Know...